Poverty wages behind Cambodian garment workers collapsing

When Neang Sokly woke up under a tree outside the Conpress garment factory where she has worked for the last two years, she screamed for help. The last thing she remembered was seeing factory security guards directing workers to get out of the building and going to investigate. “I went to see what the problem was and I passed a pile of jeans being dyed. The smell was horrible. I realized it must be from chemicals so I started to run out of the factory, but I fainted,” remembers Neang.

She is just one of hundreds employed in Cambodia’s garment manufacturing industry, producing clothing for the world’s biggest brands, such as Puma, H&M and Nike, who have fainted on the job this year alone. During a single week in July over two hundred workers were admitted to the Prek Anhchanh Health Center, a small rural clinic on the outskirts of Phnom Penh, after collapsing at work.

“I don’t remember what happened,” says Sao Nari, a 22-year-old seamstress employed at the Chinese-owned Sixplus factory, where she sews the elastic waistbands into Adidas sports shorts. “I was working in the back of the factory and I saw people running out, but I didn’t know what was happening. I started to run out as well, but there was a strange odour I had never smelled before. Then I fainted outside.” Hooked up to an IV drip in Prek Anchanch, she complained of lingering chest pains nearly three hours later.

Yet fainting workers could be considered lucky. At the New Archid and Sangwoo garment factories, located in Kandal and Kampong Speu provinces respectively, Sokny Say of the Free Trade Union of Workers of the Kingdom of Cambodia (FTUWKC) reported that two workers died last month from factory-related ailments. Thirty-five year-old seamstress Nov Pas, who spent nearly four years making clothes for brands like Gap and Old Navy, passed out at her post in the Sangwoo factory at 8am on 24 July 2014. By 9am she had been admitted to the nearest provincial hospital, and around 6pm she was pronounced dead. 

When contacted for comment, Chea Sok Thong of the Korean-owned Sangwoo factory denied corporate responsibility for Ms. Nov’s death, claiming medical carelessness from the hospital where she was receiving treatment. When questioned about the reason for her presence in the hospital in the first place, Chea stated only that “she seemed sick and weak,” but was adamant that it was unrelated to working conditions.

Sithyneth Ry, a labour resolution officer from FTUWKC, while agreeing that there is room for improvement in how garment workers are treated in hospitals, offers sharp criticism of Sangwoo’s official position. “Excuses about illnesses not being related to work are very common. [The factories] will always try to avoid being responsible.” Ultimately, he asserts, it is the responsibility of the factory to provide a safe working environment.

Though proving culpability for such episodes of mass fainting and death is a complex issue mired in the notoriously corrupt context of Cambodian bureaucracy, Mr. Sithyneth says everything is centred around one fundamental fact: garment workers are not provided with a livable wage. “In my opinion US$200 a month is the minimum amount required to live in modern Cambodia,” says Sithyneth, “but garment workers make half of that unless they work a lot of overtime hours.”

According to Sithyneth, overwork and poor workplace conditions are two of the reccurring factors responsible for the majority of fainting incidents – and both of these issues are a direct result of the financial burdens shouldered by garment workers.

Neang Sokly has worked in the garment industry for eighteen years. Currently she is employed in the quality control department of Conpress Factory Holdings Ltd., where she checks over a thousand pairs of jeans each day to make sure they meet customer standards before being shipped to international retail outlets. Her basic salary is US$124 per month, with which she has to support herself, her aging parents, and her three unemployed siblings. Even with their extremely modest lifestyle, her wages are simply not enough to cover basic expenses – leading her to actively seek as many overtime hours as are available.

“I always try to work eleven hours if possible. I want to help my family, and if I work less I cannot help them,” says Neang. “Next month there are no extra orders [at Conpress] so I will not earn any extra money. Without overtime our lives become very difficult.”

During one such overtime shift, Neang recalls when one of her co-workers collapsed at work, but they were unable to help. “She called me from the hospital [after she fainted] asking for help, but we had an urgent order so we were not allowed to leave.”

Though union intervention has largely stopped the practice of forced overtime, the financial realities faced by garment workers – the majority of whom come from impoverished families – make extra work essential, if not officially obligatory.

These long hours expose workers to the often inadequate conditions inside garment factories for far longer than is healthy. Sao Nari, who has fainted twice in her four months of employment at Conpress, remembers the same chemical smell in the air each time she collapsed. “I felt like I was suffocating,” she recalls, “I couldn’t breathe. I don’t know what the smell was, and the managers wouldn’t tell us.”

Yet the thought of quitting her job at the factory, despite her family’s concern for her wellbeing is not a plausible option. “I’m the only person in my family with a job, and we have a lot of debt from building our house. Without this job and overtime hours, I don’t know what we would do.”

In the opinion of Mr. Sithyneth of FTUWKC, the effects of poverty on the home life of garment workers could be as responsible for fainting as the long hours. A study from the British National Health Service recommends that an average woman consume roughly two thousand calories per day in order to maintain a healthy weight. Yet because of their low salaries, many garment workers are malnourished.

Twenty-four year-old Chang Savy, who has fainted twice at work in the Conpress factory, says she and her husband have just US$30 per month to spend on food. “I often feel dizzy at work and I don’t know why,” reports Chang. “Maybe I fainted because I don’t eat enough. My husband and I eat just half a cup of rice each per meal, and maybe a little bit of soup. We rarely can eat meat.” With the United States Department of Agriculture estimating that half a cup of cooked white rice contains just one hundred and twenty calories, Chang falls well below the caloric requirements necessary to maintain energy for a full workday.

Neang Sokly, who also reports not having enough disposable income to eat properly, recognizes that her poverty means she has little choice but to keep working in garment factories. Yet she credits the arrival of worker’s unions in Cambodia as improving their situation drastically. “Before the unions conditions were horrible. [The unions] have improved both the conditions and our pay. With all of us standing together, the owners must treat us better,” Neang states.

In an effort to improve the lot of her fellow garment workers, Neang volunteers as a representative for various union groups that give her funding to purchase medical supplies which she distributes to those in need. Furthermore, the presence of unions allows her to report worker abuse and exploitation. “Without the unions, things would be very bad. The unions make our voices heard.”

Sweden welcomes trade unionist as prime minister

The election results mean a return to a socialist government after eight years of conservative rule in Sweden.

A welder by trade, Löfven rose from the ranks of membership of IndustriALL Global Union affiliate IF Metall to become president of one of Sweden’s largest trade unions.  He was also a member of the Executive Committee of the International Metal Workers’ Federation (IMF).

In the opening speech at IndustriALL’s founding congress in Copenhagen 2012, Stefan Löfven said:

“Wherever there is a political discussion, workers’ voice should be heard and respected. I’m still one of you, I’ll always be.”

IndustriALL general secretary Jyrki Raina says:

“We congratulate our comrade on this huge achievement and we are proud to see a trade unionist run a country. Whatever challenges lie ahead, Stefan is a highly experienced negotiator with strong democratic roots.”
 

Women form a subregional network to promote ratification of ILO Convention 183

The meeting was addressed by representatives from the ILO, the Philippines employers' federation and trade unions. The convention has five core elements, which are maternity leave, cash benefits, health protection at work, employment protection and non-discrimination and breast feeding arrangements. No country in the Asia region has ratified the convention. Governments and employers consider the gaps between national practice and the convention clauses to be too wide. In actual fact the stumbling block is likely to be the scope of the convention. The convention is supposed to be applied to all working women, even precarious workers in the informal economy. That is at the same time why it is necessary, for contract workers as a rule do not enjoy maternity rights.

For trade unions maternity protection is part of the agenda for women's rights which also includes gender equality, work-life balance and the insistence on more women in trade unions. Maternity and paternity have to be seen as a collective responsibility. Moreover family burdens and joys have to be shared equally between mothers and fathers. Maternity protection should be addressed in the framework of social protection policies to reduce poverty and inequalities.

What the women can do to get the convention ratified is first get agreements among all trade unions and federations that they will work together on it as a priority issue, then talk with civil society organizations and NGO's. They should develop a network, get involved, do research, go to hearings, talk to the media. In Cambodia there is good experience of broadcasting concerns on the radio. The ILO national offices can be approached for technical assistance and support for activities.

In addition the women felt that they should develop a subregional position on maternity rights that could be reflected in collective bargaining clauses. The importance of maternity rights for contract workers cannot be stressed enough.

The women agreed to do research, collect data, lobby ministries, distribute information and campaign on particular days of relevance to women such as 7 October (international Day of Decent Work), 25 November (international Day to Fight Violence against Women) and 8 March (international Women's Day). They created a Facebook page for IndustriALL women to campaign for ILO Convention 183.

The day before this workshop the National Women's Forum on Reproductive Health Rights at Work was held. It was attended by about 80 women. Here again it was important to treat maternity in the framework of other women's health issues, including HIV/AIDS. The ALU union is working together with the Philippines Ministry of Public Health to create awareness of HIV and AIDS as part of its trade union work.

Unsafe garment industry needs trade unions

The factory was a disaster waiting to happen. Ali Enterprises was not registered under Pakistan’s factory Act; the building structure was not legally approved by the Building authority; the majority of the workers did not have appointment letters; all worked under an illegal third party contact system with working hours ranging from ten to 14 hours a day without overtime; the majority of workers were not registered with the Social Security Institute and Old Age Benefits Institute which is mandatory. And as there was no trade union, there was no right to collective bargaining.

In an ironic twist of events, the factory had received a clean sheet from an international social auditing company merely two weeks before the inferno broke out, certifying that all was according to standard.

The fire turned the factory into a death trap. More than 600 workers were trapped inside the factory which had no functional fire extinguishing system, all windows were closed and covered with iron rods and all exit door were forcibly locked preventing the workers to escape before all merchandise was recovered from the fire.

After spending five months in jail, the owners of Ali Enterprises were released on bail.

Few unions in the garment industry

The garment industry accounts for 65 per cent of Pakistan’s economy. 60 per cent of the country’s total workforce in the garment sector with everything raw cotton to ready-made garments.

The deadly fire two years ago sparked a small-scale debate on work safety and working conditions, but it in a country with 60 million workers without basic labour rights the discussion soon died out.

Traditionally, factory owners and local administration have come down hard on attempts to form trade unions. As a consequence, less than two per cent of the garment workers are unionised.

IndustriALL Global Union affiliate National Trade Union Federation, Pakistan (NTUF) joined forces with other labour and human rights organizations to find those responsible for the tragedy.

A commission was established to find cause and responsibility of the fire. A report was submitted to the government with the findings, but even two years after the tragedy the government refuses to make it public.

Some families of deceased workers have received partial compensation, while many are still waiting for the compensation. Following pressure from international and domestic trade unions and labour organisations, the German brand Kik, who sourced from the factory, has committed to provide 1 million USD as initial compensation.
 
Nasir Mansoor, Deputy General Secretary of NTUF says:

“We achieved this thanks to a great show of global solidarity, but we still have a long way to go. In countries like Pakistan where injustice becomes law, workers have no choice than to start resistance.”

IndustriALL Assistant General Secretary Monika Kemperle says:

“Unsafe textile factories are not only found in Bangladesh. The problems are many and complicated in Pakistan and there is no Accord on Bulding and Fire Safety to set legally binding standards.”

Increasing union membership and achieving collective bargaining are important steps. We support the work of our affiliate to make the garment industry in Pakistan safe.

The critical analysis of the antilabor law in Kazakhstan is submitted to the ILO

CFTUK in the review in details analyzes articles of the new law "About Labor Unions" which seriously limit opportunities for activity of the trade-union movement of the country. According to the law, labor unions have to be created on territorial and exclusively branch sign. Again created association of workers will receive temporary registration, but within six months it is necessary to designate belonging to branch structure and respectively to Republican. Otherwise registration will be cancelled.

It is specified in the document that the law enters trade-union monopoly at the branch level as such opportunities in Kazakhstan with assistance of the state has only the Federation of Trade unions of Kazakhstan (FTUK) possesses. The existing independent labor unions will also have to enter into the general centralized system. Thus, this law limits the right for independent activity of labor unions and creates prerequisites for centralization and controllability from under control to government institutions of FTUK. Again created and existing labor unions with the purposes and tasks will be deprived of opportunity to work independently and to defend interests of workers.

In the review of CFTUK submitted to the ILO, there are also other acts limiting trade-union activity, – formation of unregistered labor unions (including parties), as well as participation in them, according to new Criminal Code, is punished by criminal liability, provides imprisonment about three months according to article 403. The organization and participation in "illegal strikes" is punished by three years' prison punishment. Serious crime remains and "kindling of social discord" within article 164 and about 12 years of imprisonment are punished.

In June, 2014 the senate of parliament of the Republic of Kazakhstan, adopted the law "About Labor Unions" which deprives of the right of workers for association in the organizations. Besides, senators accepted new versions of Criminal, Criminal procedure and Administrative codes. New amendments impose criminal liability for participation in the labor conflicts and formulate new crimes and legal terms about activity of labor unions, opposition and public organizations.

The leading human rights associations passed unambiguously an opinion on this innovation, having declared that the provision on "illegal intervention of members of public associations in activity of government bodies" due to the lack of clear and unambiguous interpretation of the concept "illegal intervention" will allow government bodies to treat any fair requirement of the public in the person of members of public associations as illegal intervention in their activity and will nullify public control in the country".

The new laws directed against workers, are adopted in anticipation of new mass privatization, including the enterprises where there was almost eight-months strike of oil industry workers to Zhanaozene, and increases in norms of operation in all branches of economy not to allow the organized resistance from labor collectives and to put their fight beyond the law.

Goodyear Unions Committed to Revive Global Network

The Goodyear Global Network worked over the priorities of exchange of information and experience; support actions in union organizing; improvement of occupational health and safety conditions; and active international solidarity among the participating unions.

In the meantime, Goodyear unions in the Asia Pacific region cooperated through a regional network through a series of physical meetings held in 2000, 2002, 2005 and 2008 over health and safety matters with hazardous materials at plants; industrial accidents and occupational diseases; safety committees –composition, and activities-training.

Hosted by IndustriALL Global Union’s Turkish affiliate Lastik-Is, Rubber, Chemical and Oil Industry Workers’ Union, representing Goodyear workers in two plants located in Izmit and Adapazari, on 4-5 September, the 2014 global union network meeting discussed burning issues related to the tire industry in general and particular matters regarding Goodyear.

“As the first global one in the tire industry, the Goodyear network has played a very important role for international solidarity” said Abdullah Karacan, General President of Lastik-Is. “I do believe that after this meeting each of us will be conducting our day-to-day action in a more effective way”.

According to recent estimations, “the automotive tire market is set to reach close to US$250 billion globally within the next five years”. It is reported that there are between 700 and 800 tire-makers in the world, and probably near 650 in China.

The Izmit meeting endorsed and appreciated IndustriALL Global Union’s key strategies and actions, particularly on trade union networks.  Goodyear unions elaborated global trends in the tire Industry with a particular focus on Goodyear through a global overview of the economic situation, investments and employment.

One important item discussed was the trade union situation in Goodyear operations worldwide. Tom O'Shei and Jim Mason from the United Steelworkers of North America briefed the participants on the collective bargaining process in the US plants since 2006. The Turkish case presented by Lastik-Is attracted attention of the delegates with new gained rights such as complementary public scheme.

The meeting finally discussed a further work plan and how to keep the network functioning with a unanimous decision to revive the structure.

The delegates later visited the Goodyear plant in Izmit, capital of the tire industry in Turkey, and met with factory management, shop stewards and workers after a tour. The plant is nearly one-hundred percent unionized and therefore the union has real power and is because of that totaly accepted by the management. It was a good example, the power of the union is its members.

“IndustriALL Global Union’s strategy in the tire industry is to build global union power through strong networks,” said Kemal Özkan, Assistant General Secretary. “The Goodyear global union network will continue to play an important role in this strategy”.

Goodyear is one of the world's leading tire companies, particularly in North America and Latin America as number one and in Europe as the second largest tire maker. Goodyear employs approximately 69,000 people around the world operating 51 plants in 22 countries. Its major brands are Goodyear, Dunlop Tires, Kelly Tires, Fulda, Sava and Debica.

Turkish Glass Workers Reach Collective Agreement After Strike Ban

According to Turkish legislation, “a lawful strike or lock-out that has been called or commenced may be suspended by the Council of Ministers for 60 days with a decree if it is prejudicial to public health or national security. The suspension shall come into force on the date of publication of the decree“.

The legislation further reads “if an agreement is not reached before the expiry date of the suspension period, the High Board of Arbitration settles the dispute upon the application of either party within six working days. Otherwise, the competence of the workers’ trade union shall be void”. It is a well-known fact that the High Arbitration Board never rules in favour of union demands because it is dominated by government and employers’ representatives. This is why Kristal-Is has pursued a strategy to conclude the agreement without going to compulsory arbitration.

In the meantime, Kristal-Is has applied to the State Council for nullification of the Government’s Decree with a demand of suspension of its execution for being able to continue to strike. However surprisingly the State Council has refused this demand on the contrary to its earlier jurisprudence on the basis of economic arguments rather than protecting fundamental rights. In addition to this, Kristal-Is has filed a complaint against Turkish Government at the ILO over violation of the right of collective bargaining, and IndustriALL Global Union supported it. In the meantime, Kristal-Is and its members engaged in a series of nationwide actions.

Before the sixty-day suspension period was about to be over, Kristal-Is has organized a secret-ballot vote on 26 August with its members over the last offer made by the employers at the onoging negotiations. On the basis of the results and potential risk that the collective agreement be concluded by the High Arbitration Committee, Kristal-Is has decided to sign.

The new agreement has brought important achievements to the union members. With the new deal, wages were increased with an average of 14% and a substantial improvement has been made for lower-paid categories. Bonuses and other social payments were augmented by between 10% and 49%.

The agreement covers 5800 glass workers in ten factories of Sisecam group, namely Trakya Cam, Trakya Mersin, Trakya Yenişehir, Trakya Otocam, Cam Elyaf, Paşabahçe Eskişehir, Paşabahçe Mersin, Paşabahçe Kırklareli, Anadolu Cam Mersin and Anadolu Cam Yenişehir.

Kemal Özkan, Assistant General Secretary of IndustriALL stated:

IndustriALL Global Union salutes and congratulates Kristal-Is over its determination for better wages and working conditions during this difficult period. Our right to strike is under threat worldwide. The strike ban in the Turkish glass industry is a clear example of how this fundamental right is critical for us since the strike is a vital instrument for workers in betterment and advancement of their rights and interests.

IndustriALL joins mourning for five killed miners in Bosnia

The last of the five Bosnian miners’ bodies was recovered late Sunday, 7 September. The five were killed after an earthquake triggered a collapse inside the central Raspotocje mine near the town of Zenica, central Bosnia and Herzegovina.

The 3.5-magnitude earthquake caused explosive fractures in the rocks as flammable methane gas pockets were released. The collapsed shafts trapped 34 miners, 29 of whom were rescued within 24 hours of the accident. The joint memorial of the five killed miners took place on Monday in Zenica, with thousands of people attending. The five were then buried in village cemeteries near the town.

Raspotocje has a reputation as Bosnia’s most dangerous coal mine, with frequent rock bursts and accidents. Raspotocje produces coal for Bosnia’s largest power utility, EPBiH, and employs 430 miners. The authorities have not addressed the safety concerns since war damage sustained during the 1990s.

The Raspotocje mine was one of seven coalmines merged in 2009 by the government to supply the EPHiH utility’s coal-fired energy plants. As part of that deal EPBiH pledged to invest more than 70,000 Euros over five years to improve working conditions. Although that money has been spent, almost none has gone to Raspotocje.

IndustriALL Global Union general secretary Raina sent written condolences to president Sinan Husic of the union organizing the mine, the Independent Miners Trade Union of the BIH Federation:

This is a sad and tragic reminder of the importance of ensuring safe and healthy working conditions for miners all over the world, in full accordance with national labour legislation and international core labour standards, including the International Labour Organization’s Convention 176 on Safety and Health in Mines. We strongly encourage the government of Bosnia and Herzegovina to implement its plan to vastly upgrade the operation at the Raspotocje coal mine and improve working conditions.

An injury to one is an injury to all.

Global unions unite to back Cambodian garment workers’ action day

IndustriALL Global Union, UNI Global Union and the International Trade Union Confederation (ITUC) are joining Cambodian garment workers in a day of action on 17 September calling for a rise in the minimum wage from US$100 to US$177.  

In early October, the Labour Advisory Committee (LAC) in Cambodia is set to announce a new minimum wage for workers in the garment, textile and footwear industry, which generates US$5 billion in revenue for the country.

At this critical juncture, IndustriALL, the ITUC and UNI are asking affiliates to take part in the global day of action by organizing protests outside Cambodian embassies and present a letter to the ambassador. Affiliates are also being asked to send letters directly to the Cambodian Prime Minister Hun Sen.

Jyrki Raina, general secretary of IndustriALL, said:

“The global day of action on 17 September will be a sharp reminder that the world is watching as Cambodia sets a new minimum wage. Cambodia is an important sourcing country to the fashion industry and yet pitiful wages mean that garment workers live in poverty and are forced to work exhausting hours to survive. We urge the Cambodian government to listen to workers’ demands for a peaceful path to a just wage – or seriously risk jeopardizing brands’ confidence in the country as a sourcing partner.”

A coalition of garment unions, including IndustriALL affiliates, agreed on the figure of US$177 based on a study commissioned by the Cambodian government for the LAC. The study found that the minimum wage should be between $157 and $177 dollars a month. This number is also close to the amount had the original minimum wage for the sector been adjusted for inflation over time – around $170.

Philip Jennings, General Secretary of UNI Global Union said, “Cambodia has a choice, either to take the high road to becoming a sustainable, ethical, fair play industry or the low road that leads to the bottom. The eyes of everyone from consumers to brands are on Cambodia. Cambodia do the right thing and raise the minimum wage to US$177.”

Sharan Burrow, General Secretary of the International Trade Union Confederation, further explained:

“The impoverishment of workers in supply chains is a global scandal. In Cambodia, garment workers’ labour supports a multi-billion dollar industry, while wages are insufficient to cover basic expenses, including adequate food and shelter for themselves and their families. Cambodia will simply not move forward if the economic strategy is to continue to rely on a poverty wage system. We strongly support the unions’ call for a living wage and urge the government to act now.”

Ends

For more information please contact:

Leonie Guguen

[email protected]

Tel: 00 41 (0)22 308 50 24

[email protected]

Switchboard: 00 41 (0)22 308 50 50

www.industriall-union.org

Juno Lighting workers celebrate the joy of victory

The workers went on strike as the last remedy in their fight for decent conditions and fair wages after several months of negotiations prior to the end of the previous agreement in August.

At the end of the strike the Chicago and Midwest Regional Joint Board representing the striking workers shared the information about Juno Lighting workers’ victory. Reportedly the newly reached deal includes an average wage increase from US$11.90 to US$13.30 per hour. Also workers managed to obtain improvements in many other benefits including the double sick pay and a decrease in the cost of family insurance.

In his letter to IndustriALL Richard Monje, International vice president of Workers United/SEIU praised the support of the IndustriALL Global Union family playing an important role in assuring justice for Juno workers, he said, “this is a victory not only for Workers United members at Juno Lighting but for global labor solidarity“.

IndustriALL Global Union Assistant General Secretary Kemal Özkan commented on the victory, “We are indeed glad that the dispute at Juno Lighting Group is over and the management of the Group came quickly to its senses and made the right choice when it accepted the workers’ demands. We salute the determination of Juno workers and share their joy of victory with all our members across the globe."